Social Input

One of the issues that seemed to arise during our conversations is the idea of gaining public support for projects and plans around the city.  However, with the government owning the land and having the ability to “buy out” residents and move them elsewhere to gain space for future malls and high rise building, one has to wonder how much public input they are really wanting.  Another question that came to me is would the level of growth and the type of development occurred in Hong Kong if there was more public support.  As a comparison, it’s taken us in Seattle years to get the 520 bridge tolled and an alternative the viaduct.  So it’s hard to say what the absolute right level of each is most efficient.

After control of the former colony was turned over to mainland China, Hong Kong has continued to thrive as the economic powerhouse of the developing Chinese economy.  Back in 2007, the GDP per capita was a little over $40,000 but the mainland was only between $5,000 and $6,000.  Recently, Shanghai has surpassed Hong Kong in GDP but with a population that is double of Hong Kong, it was inevitable.

The one advantage Hong Kong has over other Chinese cities is the long history of British regulation and oversight.  This translates into many investors wanting to buy property in Hong Kong because the property laws are so clear and they know their assets will be secure.

Another advantage Hong Kong maintains politically over mainland China is the continued influence of the former British rule and this helps them maintain some economic freedom and political autonomy.  They still maintain a semi-direct democracy and still have in their constitution the promise of universal suffrage by 2007.  However this has been postponed to 2012 and then again to 2017.  This apparent “dragging of feet” has prompted some protesting but even with the push for democracy there is a widespread conservatism and cautiousness of Hong Kong residents as a whole.

Although these protests may indicate a massive support for democracy and a “people’s voice”, there are many others that are more concerned with their economic rights over their political rights.  As long as incomes and standard of living will continue to rise, the political needs will fall second to economic needs.  As long as the government can continue to pay above “market” to transplant individuals for prime development land and their standard of living can increase, most of the movements may continue to be grassroots and isolated to a few who see political freedom as a fundamental necessity to the masses of Hong Kong.




This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Social Input

  1. A-P Hurd says:

    it’s interesting that you say people want to buy in HK because they feel their property rtights are so clear, but you allude to government expropriation at the beginning and end of your article. how can both be true at once? Do you mean that western capital generally flows to HK because of it’s robust financial services sector and relatively strong IP protections?

    • mweigum says:

      Yea now thinking about it that would probably help with the posting. I guess I was trying to refer to this seemingly false layer of public opinion the government is saying they are trying to elicit but in the end if they want to tear down something for the sake of something else they could.

  2. chris says:

    I think it’s misleading to think of Hong Kong as an economic powerhouse of growth in China. HK has been in long-term decline since the 80s. Their biggest drop was in 1998 and they’ve been falling steadily in relative importance and prestige ever since. I am having a hard time correlating your comments to the realities I’ve experienced as a person with family and financial ties to HK who has been visiting almost every year for the last 20 years.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s